Sumail vs. Evil Geniuses Legal Case Proceeds to Court

Sumail vs. Evil Geniuses Legal Case Proceeds to Court

Harrison Htet

13 Aug, 2023, 19:22

|

Last updated: 11 Apr, 2025, 09:15

One of the Dota 2 legends, Sumail "Sumail" Hassan, will not be making an appearance on The International stage. However, there is another place where Sumail will be making an appearance. He will take the stand as his legal battle with his former team, Evil Geniuses, is heading to trial.

The Case

In March 2023, news about the player and the team’s ongoing legal battle, which dates back to December 2021, surfaced. The case focuses on how Evil Geniuses as an organisation took advantage of a “young, naive and vulnerable” player during and after his time on the team. The party representing the player claimed a 40 000 share ownership stake was given to Sumail in the company when he signed a five-year contract with Evil Geniuses in September 2016. However, in May 2019, Sumail’s stake was converted into mixed stock when the ownership of EG changed.

The Witnesses

In the summer, both legal parties were busy readying the witnesses for deposition testimony. Evil Geniuses’s legal team requested to exclude any “late disclosed witnesses”, but their attempt failed. Although the witnesses list is vague, it includes several familiar names for many Dota 2 fans. It contains former teammates of the player.  Clinton “Fear” Loomis, Artour “Arteezy” Babaev, and Saahil “Universe” Arora are a few names that popped up on the list, along with the team’s former Chief Operating Officer, Philip Aram.

New Details

In new details that surfaced, EG made several requests for admission, addressing the player's claims. One of them being in a meeting, the former CEO of the EG, Nicole Lapointe Jameson, advised the young player to consult an attorney before he signed anything on the paper. However, along with several other claims, this claim was also denied.

The trial of the player against the team will commence on November 6th. Currently, both involved parties are getting their testimony ready. More information about the case will come to light in October.

Image Source: Flickr

Latest news

FISSURE CEO Acknowledges Unpaid Prize Money, Targets 2027 Repayments

FISSURE CEO Acknowledges Unpaid Prize Money, Targets 2027 Repayments

FISSURE CEO Nikolay Vesnin has acknowledged outstanding Dota 2 and CS2 prize money and outlined a conditional repayment plan for early 2027.
7 Nov
Bruno Rodrigues

Evil Geniuses to Shut Down Esports Operations

After more than 25 years in esports, Evil Geniuses has announced it will end competitive and day-to-day operations on November 2, 2026.
21 Oct
Bruno Rodrigues

Dota 2 Player Scores 32 Kills to Convince Police to Release His Teammates

According to 23savage, police released his teammates only after watching him score 32 kills with Kez in a game of Dota 2.
17 Oct
Bruno Rodrigues

Team Liquid Signs TI 2025 Champion Malr1ne to Replace Nisha

TI 2025 champion Malr1ne joins Team Liquid as Nisha's replacement following Team Falcons' departure from Dota 2. The new roster is expected to debut at PARI Universe on October 22.
15 Oct
Bruno Rodrigues

Esports to Exit Asian Games After 2026, New Dedicated Event Confirmed for 2027 [UPDATED]

The OCA has confirmed a new Asian Esports and Mind Sports Games in Kuwait for 2027, bringing a dedicated esports event to the region.
27 Sep
Sofia Guimarães

Indonesia to Host the IESF World Esports Championship 2026

The IESF World Esports Championship 2026 is heading to Indonesia, bringing together athletes from around the world across five esports titles.
23 Sep
Sofia Guimarães

South American Dota 2 Sees A Path Back After ESIC Bans Vintage and DarkMago

The bans against Vintage and DarkMago give South American Dota 2 a clear point to address match-fixing concerns and rebuild trust across its competitive scene.
12 Sep
André Guaraldo

Comments (0)

Log in to comment on this match