
If you enjoy the English Premier League (EPL), you likely own a few trading cards of your favorite team or player. Currently, the most valuable Premier League Card by asking price is the 2025 Topps Now Premier League Foilfractor Erling Haaland 1/1 #27 PSA 9 MINT valued at $300,000. Based on our findings, rarity drives this product’s price, including 1/1 numbering, PSA grades, and real player autographs.
If you ask a few Premier League fans, you’ll likely get different answers. And that’s expected, as people have emotional ties to a particular player or club. So, we set out to put the debate to rest by creating a list of the five top cards.
| Rank | Card | Grade | Price | Basis for pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2025 Topps Now Premier League Foilfractor Erling Haaland 1/1 #27 | PSA 9 | $300,000 | Asking price/estimated value |
| 2 | 2023-24 Topps Chrome Premier League Erling Haaland Superfractor 1/1 | PSA 10 | $100,000 | Estimated value |
| 3 | 2025-26 Topps Chrome Premier League Max Dowman Chrome Auto-Red Geometric | PSA 9 | $29,280 | Confirmed sale (May 2026) |
| 4 | 2021-22 Panini National Treasures Premier League Phil Foden / Bukayo Saka True Logoman Auto 1/1 | Ungraded | $30,000 to $60,000 | Estimated value |
As you can see, the most expensive Premier League card is the 2025 Topps Now Premier League Foilfractor Erling Haaland 1/1 #27. But that’s just the asking price, not the actual sale. That means final sales can go either higher or lower. However, if you want to rank these cards based solely on sales data, then the Max Dowman card tops the list.
It boils down to a few factors, which are similar to those that influenced the most valuable NHL card in sports history:
When few copies of a card exist, you can expect more collectors to fight hard to get it. And as you can see from our rankings, the most expensive EPL cards are numbered 1/1. Which means there’s only one copy in existence.
These are cards based on a player’s first appearance in the EPL. The truth is, they’re not especially valuable when they’re first printed. Rather, they grow in value over time, especially if the player does well in the league. That’s the case with Erling Haaland, which is why his two designated EPL cards, 2025 Topps Now and 2023-24 Topps Chrome, are currently the most expensive.
It’s no secret that some EPL cards feature printed signatures. But nothing beats a card that a player holds and signs personally. That itself can triple its value. And if there’s something to think about, the most valuable NBA card is autographed and was sold for $12.9 million.
This is another factor whereby a player’s popularity directly impacts the value of their cards. But the reverse is also true. If such a player gets transferred out of the Premier League to another league or faces a season-long injury, the card values may drop.
Everyone loves an underdog story, and in the Premier League, there’s always a handful of them every season. Remember when Leicester City returned to the league in the 2014/15 season after 10 years of absence? And they went on to win the league, a year later? Stories like these can lift key player prices.
Think of the youngest player to score in the EPL. That’s right: Max Dowman was only 16 years and 73 days old when he scored for Arsenal against Everton on March 14, 2026. And by the season’s end, he became the youngest Premier League title winner. So, it’s not surprising the Dowman story got him the most expensive EPL card by actual sales.
This factor is where things get picky and can actually affect the card’s value. When a card is submitted to third-party graders like Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), they examine just about everything. They check whether:
If you think that’s too much for an EPL card, this same criteria is applied to any collectible card. That’s why the most valuable Pokémon card on record got its price through a near-flawless grade, not hype alone. Put simply, a mint copy and a beat-up one are barely the same card when money talks, which is why top grades like a PSA 10 Mint command the biggest premiums.
Please take a look at the perks and downsides of getting the most valuable EPL cards.
2025 Topps Now Premier League Foilfractor Erling Haaland 1/1 #27 leads on paper with a $300,000 asking price. On the other hand, 2025-26 Topps Chrome Premier League Max Dowman Chrome Auto-Red Geometric is the most expensive based on reported sales.
If you’re interested in chasing your own pull, which could perhaps become one of the most valuable EPL cards, click the banners on this page to explore our available card rip sites.
Erling Haaland’s 1/1 Topps Now Foilfractor, with a $300,000 asking price. That’s a seller’s ask, not a confirmed sale. The biggest confirmed sale we found is 2025-26 Topps Chrome Premier League Max Dowman Chrome Auto-Red Geometric PSA 9 at $29,280.
He scored at 16 years and 73 days old, making him the youngest scorer in Premier League history, and then won the EPL title with Arsenal.
Some are, and many are not. A base Haaland Prizm card in PSA 10 sold for about $20 to $50 in 2023 and 2024, while top cards reach five figures.